Tue. Nov 5th, 2024

WordPress is a powerful and versatile platform that has been used by millions of people to create websites, blogs, and online stores. But is WordPress a software developer? In this article, we will explore the role of WordPress in software development and whether it can be considered a software developer in its own right. We will examine the capabilities of WordPress and how it can be used to build complex software applications. So, let’s dive in and uncover the truth about WordPress’s role in software development.

What is WordPress?

A Brief History of WordPress

WordPress is an open-source content management system (CMS) that was first released in 2003. It was created by Michel Valdrighi and was originally designed as a simple system for creating blogs. However, over time, WordPress has evolved into a powerful platform that can be used for a wide range of website development projects.

Here are some key milestones in the history of WordPress:

  • 2003: WordPress was first released as a free and open-source software.
  • 2005: The WordPress community was formed, and the first official version of the software was released.
  • 2010: WordPress.com was launched, offering users a hosted version of the platform.
  • 2013: WordPress became the most popular CMS in use, with over 60 million websites built on the platform.
  • 2015: WordPress was acquired by Automattic, a company founded by Matt Mullenweg, one of the original developers of the platform.
  • 2021: WordPress celebrates its 18th birthday, and continues to be one of the most popular CMSs in use, with over 75 million websites built on the platform.

Throughout its history, WordPress has been shaped by the contributions of a large and active community of developers, designers, and users. This community has helped to make WordPress the versatile and powerful platform that it is today, and continues to drive its development and growth.

Key Features of WordPress

Flexibility and Customization

WordPress is known for its flexibility and customization options. It allows developers to build websites and applications with a wide range of plugins and themes. This makes it easy to add functionality and change the look and feel of a website or application to meet specific needs.

Open-Source and Free

WordPress is an open-source platform, which means that it is free to use, modify, and distribute. This allows developers to use the platform as a foundation for their projects and customize it to their specific needs without worrying about licensing fees or restrictions.

Content Management System (CMS)

WordPress is a content management system (CMS) that allows users to easily create and manage content on their websites. It provides a user-friendly interface for adding and editing text, images, and other media, as well as organizing content into pages and posts.

Scalability

WordPress is designed to be scalable, which means that it can handle a large volume of traffic and data. This makes it a good choice for large websites and applications that need to handle a high volume of users and data.

Security

WordPress takes security seriously and has implemented various measures to protect websites and applications built on the platform. It provides regular updates to address security vulnerabilities and has features such as two-factor authentication and password strength requirements to help keep user data secure.

WordPress as a Platform for Software Development

Key takeaway: WordPress is a powerful and flexible platform for software development, offering features such as flexibility and customization, a vast community of developers, and support for integrating with other tools and services. However, it is important to be aware of its limitations, including security concerns, performance issues, and scalability limitations. Additionally, it is worth considering alternatives such as headless CMS options, which offer greater flexibility and scalability. Ultimately, the choice of platform will depend on the specific needs of the software development project.

Creating Custom Plugins and Themes

One of the key strengths of WordPress is its ability to be easily extended and customized through the use of plugins and themes. These customizations can be used to add new functionality to a website or to change the way it looks and feels.

In terms of software development, WordPress provides a flexible and powerful platform for creating custom plugins and themes. This can be particularly useful for businesses or organizations that need to develop custom software solutions that are tailored to their specific needs.

When it comes to creating custom plugins and themes, WordPress offers a range of tools and resources that make the process as simple and straightforward as possible. For example, the WordPress plugin repository provides access to thousands of free and paid plugins that can be easily installed and activated on a website. Similarly, the WordPress theme directory offers a wide range of free and paid themes that can be used to change the look and feel of a website.

In addition to these pre-built plugins and themes, WordPress also provides a range of tools and resources for creating custom plugins and themes from scratch. This includes a powerful plugin development framework that makes it easy to create custom plugins that can add new functionality to a website. Similarly, WordPress offers a range of theme development tools that can be used to create custom themes that are tailored to a specific website or business.

Overall, the ability to create custom plugins and themes is one of the key strengths of WordPress as a platform for software development. Whether you are a business or organization looking to develop custom software solutions, or a developer looking to create new plugins and themes, WordPress provides a flexible and powerful platform that can help you achieve your goals.

Extending WordPress Capabilities with APIs

Integrating with External Services

One of the primary advantages of using WordPress as a platform for software development is its ability to integrate with external services. This is achieved through the use of APIs (Application Programming Interfaces), which allow WordPress to communicate with other software applications and systems.

Utilizing RESTful APIs

WordPress supports a variety of APIs, including RESTful APIs, which provide a set of endpoints that can be used to interact with the WordPress database. This allows developers to access and manipulate data stored within WordPress, as well as retrieve information from external sources.

Making Use of GraphQL

Another popular API used in conjunction with WordPress is GraphQL, which provides a more flexible and efficient way of querying data. With GraphQL, developers can request only the specific data they need, rather than having to retrieve entire datasets. This can lead to significant performance improvements and a more streamlined development process.

Enhancing Core Functionality

By extending WordPress capabilities with APIs, developers can also enhance the core functionality of their software applications. For example, they can add features such as user authentication, payment processing, and content management, by leveraging the power of external services.

Leveraging Third-Party Plugins and Themes

In addition to integrating with external services, WordPress also offers a vast ecosystem of third-party plugins and themes that can be used to extend its capabilities. These plugins and themes can be easily integrated into a software application, providing additional functionality and customization options.

Overall, by utilizing APIs and integrating with external services, WordPress can be transformed into a powerful platform for software development. This allows developers to access a wide range of tools and resources, enabling them to build robust and feature-rich applications with ease.

Integrating with Other Tools and Services

When it comes to software development, WordPress is not just a platform for creating websites and blogs. It can also be used as a base for building a wide range of software applications. One of the key advantages of using WordPress for software development is its ability to integrate with other tools and services.

There are a number of ways in which WordPress can be integrated with other tools and services. For example, it can be integrated with APIs to access data from external sources, or with payment gateways to handle transactions. It can also be integrated with project management tools to help teams collaborate and manage their work more effectively.

In addition to these integrations, WordPress can also be extended using plugins and themes. These extensions can add new functionality to the platform, or enhance existing features. This means that developers can tailor WordPress to meet the specific needs of their software projects, without having to build everything from scratch.

Overall, the ability to integrate with other tools and services is a key factor in the popularity of WordPress as a platform for software development. It allows developers to leverage the power of the platform, while also having access to a wide range of other tools and services that can help them build better software, faster.

The Benefits of Using WordPress for Software Development

Flexibility and Customization

One of the primary advantages of using WordPress for software development is its flexibility and customization options. With its open-source nature, WordPress allows developers to create custom themes and plugins to tailor the platform to specific business needs.

Customizable Themes

WordPress offers a vast array of themes that can be easily customized to fit the desired look and feel of a software application. From simple blogging platforms to complex e-commerce websites, WordPress themes can be modified to suit various business requirements. Developers can also create custom themes from scratch, giving them complete control over the design and layout of their software application.

Customizable Plugins

WordPress plugins offer a range of functionality, from social media integration to form builders and e-commerce functionality. Developers can customize existing plugins or create new ones to meet the specific needs of their software application. This allows for greater flexibility and ensures that the software application meets the unique requirements of the business.

WP REST API

The WP REST API is a powerful tool that allows developers to create custom endpoints for their software application. This means that developers can create custom APIs to retrieve and manipulate data, providing greater flexibility and customization options for their software application.

WordPress Gutenberg Blocks

WordPress Gutenberg blocks are a new feature that allows developers to create custom content blocks for their software application. These blocks can be used to create custom layouts and designs, giving developers greater control over the look and feel of their software application.

In conclusion, the flexibility and customization options offered by WordPress make it an ideal platform for software development. With its open-source nature, customizable themes and plugins, WP REST API, and Gutenberg blocks, developers have the tools they need to create custom software applications that meet the unique needs of their business.

Cost-Effectiveness

When it comes to software development, one of the biggest advantages of using WordPress is its cost-effectiveness. This is due to several factors, including:

  • Open-source: WordPress is an open-source platform, which means that it is free to use and can be customized to suit the needs of any project. This eliminates the need to pay for a license or any other fees associated with proprietary software.
  • Customizable: Because WordPress is open-source, it can be easily customized to meet the specific needs of a project. This allows developers to create software that is tailored to their clients’ requirements, without having to pay for expensive customization services.
  • Plugin and theme marketplaces: WordPress has a large and active community of developers who create plugins and themes that can be used to extend the functionality of a website or application. This means that developers can save time and money by using existing plugins and themes, rather than building everything from scratch.
  • Easy to learn: WordPress is relatively easy to learn, which means that developers can get up to speed quickly and start building software without having to invest a lot of time in training. This can save time and money in the long run, as developers can focus on building software rather than learning how to use a new platform.

Overall, the cost-effectiveness of WordPress makes it an attractive option for software development projects of all sizes. Whether you’re building a small website or a complex application, WordPress can help you get the job done without breaking the bank.

Ease of Use

WordPress is widely regarded as one of the most user-friendly content management systems (CMS) available today. This is especially relevant when considering its application in software development. One of the key advantages of using WordPress for software development is its ease of use. Here are some of the reasons why:

Simple User Interface

WordPress has a simple and intuitive user interface that makes it easy for developers to navigate and use. The dashboard is well-organized, with clear menus and tabs that provide quick access to all the necessary features. This means that developers can quickly learn how to use WordPress and get started with their projects without any unnecessary delays.

Customizable Themes and Plugins

WordPress is highly customizable, with a vast array of themes and plugins available that can be easily installed and configured. This allows developers to quickly and easily tailor their website or application to meet their specific needs. Additionally, WordPress’s plugin system allows developers to add functionality to their website or application without having to write custom code.

Open-Source Community

WordPress is an open-source platform, which means that it is free to use and can be customized by anyone. This has led to the creation of a large and active community of developers who contribute to the platform’s development and share their knowledge and expertise with others. This community provides a wealth of resources, including documentation, tutorials, and support forums, that can help developers get the most out of WordPress.

Easy Integration with Other Tools

WordPress can easily integrate with a wide range of other tools and platforms, including payment gateways, marketing automation tools, and analytics platforms. This makes it easy for developers to integrate WordPress into their existing workflows and automate many of their processes.

Overall, WordPress’s ease of use is a major advantage when it comes to software development. Its simple user interface, customizable themes and plugins, open-source community, and easy integration with other tools make it a powerful and flexible platform that can be used for a wide range of software development projects.

Community Support

WordPress has a thriving community of developers, designers, and users who actively contribute to the platform. This community support provides a wealth of resources for software development professionals.

One of the main benefits of the WordPress community is the vast array of plugins and themes available. These plugins and themes can be used to add functionality to a website or customize its appearance. Many of these plugins and themes are free, while others are available for purchase. The wide range of options available means that developers can find solutions to almost any problem they encounter.

Another advantage of the WordPress community is the availability of tutorials and documentation. The WordPress Codex is a comprehensive resource that provides information on everything from setting up a website to advanced development techniques. There are also numerous online forums and blogs where developers can ask questions and share knowledge with other members of the community.

In addition to the resources available online, WordPress has a number of meetups and conferences where developers can network and learn from each other. These events provide opportunities to hear from experts in the field and to learn about the latest trends and best practices.

Overall, the community support for WordPress is a major advantage for software development professionals. With access to a wealth of resources and a supportive community, developers can work more efficiently and effectively, creating high-quality websites and applications.

Challenges and Limitations of Using WordPress for Software Development

Security Concerns

One of the major challenges of using WordPress for software development is security concerns. While WordPress is an excellent platform for building websites and blogs, it is also a popular target for hackers and cybercriminals. Here are some of the security concerns associated with using WordPress for software development:

Vulnerabilities and Exploits

WordPress, like any other software, has its share of vulnerabilities and exploits. Hackers can take advantage of these vulnerabilities to gain unauthorized access to a website or compromise sensitive data. To mitigate these risks, it is essential to keep WordPress up to date with the latest security patches and updates.

Malware Infections

Malware infections are another security concern when using WordPress for software development. Hackers can use various techniques to inject malware into a website, which can then spread to other websites and compromise user data. To prevent malware infections, it is essential to use a reputable web host, keep the website clean, and use a security plugin to detect and remove malware.

Weak Passwords and User Accounts

Weak passwords and user accounts can also pose a security risk when using WordPress for software development. Hackers can use brute force attacks to guess user passwords or exploit vulnerabilities in user accounts to gain unauthorized access to a website. To prevent these types of attacks, it is essential to use strong passwords and enable two-factor authentication for user accounts.

Plugin and Theme Vulnerabilities

WordPress plugins and themes can also pose a security risk when used for software development. Hackers can exploit vulnerabilities in these third-party components to gain unauthorized access to a website or compromise sensitive data. To mitigate these risks, it is essential to use only reputable plugins and themes from trusted sources and to keep them up to date with the latest security patches and updates.

In conclusion, while WordPress is an excellent platform for software development, it is essential to be aware of the security concerns associated with using it. By keeping WordPress up to date, using strong passwords, enabling two-factor authentication, and using only reputable plugins and themes, developers can mitigate these risks and ensure the security of their software applications.

Performance Issues

WordPress is a powerful content management system (CMS) that is widely used for creating websites and blogs. While it offers many benefits, including ease of use and customization, it can also present some challenges and limitations when used for software development. One of the main issues is performance.

WordPress was originally designed as a blogging platform, and its architecture is not optimized for large-scale software development projects. As a result, it can struggle to handle high levels of traffic and may experience performance issues, such as slow page load times and increased server response times.

One of the main reasons for these performance issues is the use of a database to store content. While this is an essential feature for a CMS, it can also be a significant bottleneck when dealing with large amounts of data. Additionally, WordPress is built on PHP, which can be slow and resource-intensive, further exacerbating performance issues.

Another issue is the use of plugins, which can add functionality to a WordPress site. While plugins can be very useful, they can also slow down a site by adding additional code and increasing server load. This can be particularly problematic for software development projects that require high levels of performance and scalability.

To address these performance issues, developers can take several steps. One approach is to optimize the code and use caching plugins to reduce the load on the server. Another option is to use a content delivery network (CDN) to distribute content across multiple servers, reducing the load on any one server. Finally, developers can consider using a different platform that is better suited to the demands of software development, such as a custom-built CMS or a microservices architecture.

In conclusion, while WordPress can be a powerful tool for software development, it is important to be aware of its limitations and challenges, particularly when it comes to performance. By taking steps to optimize the code and infrastructure, developers can help ensure that their projects run smoothly and efficiently.

Scalability Limitations

While WordPress is a powerful content management system, it has limitations when it comes to software development. One of the primary challenges is scalability. As your software application grows, you may encounter issues with WordPress’s ability to handle increased traffic and user demand.

  • Insufficient resources: WordPress was designed as a blogging platform, and its architecture is not optimized for enterprise-level applications. This can lead to performance issues as your application scales, and you may find that you need to upgrade your server infrastructure or use additional plugins to compensate for this.
  • Limited customization options: While WordPress offers a wide range of plugins and themes, there may be limitations to how much you can customize the platform to meet the specific needs of your software application. This can be particularly challenging if you need to integrate your application with other systems or build custom functionality that is not available through existing plugins.
  • Security concerns: As your application grows, you may need to implement additional security measures to protect against cyber threats. However, WordPress has a history of security vulnerabilities, and you may need to invest in additional security measures or hire a dedicated security team to ensure that your application remains secure.

Overall, while WordPress can be a valuable tool for software development, it is important to carefully consider its limitations and plan accordingly to ensure that your application can scale effectively over time.

Learning Curve

When it comes to using WordPress for software development, one of the main challenges that developers may face is the learning curve associated with the platform. While WordPress is widely used for website development, it may not be immediately apparent how to leverage the platform for software development purposes.

One of the key challenges associated with the learning curve is simply becoming familiar with the platform’s architecture and how it functions. This can involve understanding the different components of WordPress, such as themes, plugins, and widgets, and how they interact with one another. Additionally, developers may need to become familiar with the WordPress codebase and how to extend the platform’s functionality through customization and development.

Another challenge associated with the learning curve is simply finding the resources and documentation necessary to learn WordPress development. While there are many online resources available for learning WordPress, it can be difficult to sift through all of the information and find the most relevant and up-to-date resources. Additionally, because WordPress is such a popular platform, there may be a lot of conflicting information or outdated resources that can be confusing for developers to navigate.

To overcome the learning curve associated with WordPress development, it can be helpful to seek out resources and communities specifically focused on software development with WordPress. This can include online forums, blogs, and tutorials that are tailored to the unique needs of software developers using the platform. Additionally, working with experienced WordPress developers or attending conferences and workshops can provide valuable insights and hands-on experience with the platform.

Overall, while the learning curve associated with WordPress development can be steep, it is important to remember that the platform offers a powerful set of tools and capabilities for software development. With the right resources and guidance, developers can overcome the challenges associated with the learning curve and leverage WordPress to build innovative and effective software solutions.

Alternatives to WordPress for Software Development

Comparison with Other CMS Platforms

When considering alternatives to WordPress for software development, it is essential to compare it with other popular CMS platforms. Some of the most commonly used CMS platforms include:

Joomla

Joomla is a free and open-source CMS platform that offers similar functionality to WordPress. It has a powerful content management system and is highly customizable. However, Joomla is often considered more complex than WordPress, which can make it difficult for beginners to use. Additionally, Joomla’s template system is not as flexible as WordPress’s, which can limit the design options for developers.

Drupal

Drupal is another popular open-source CMS platform that is often used for complex websites and web applications. It offers advanced content management features and a highly customizable architecture. However, Drupal’s learning curve is steeper than WordPress, and it can be more challenging to set up and maintain. Additionally, Drupal’s developer community is not as large as WordPress’s, which can make it harder to find support and resources.

Magento

Magento is an e-commerce platform that is built on PHP and offers a flexible and scalable solution for online stores. It has a powerful CMS system that allows for easy content management and customization. However, Magento is not as user-friendly as WordPress, and it can be more challenging to set up and maintain. Additionally, Magento’s focus on e-commerce means that it may not be the best option for developers who are building websites or web applications that do not require e-commerce functionality.

Overall, while there are alternatives to WordPress for software development, it remains the most popular and widely used CMS platform. Its user-friendly interface, extensive library of plugins and themes, and large developer community make it an attractive option for developers of all skill levels.

Exploring Headless CMS Options

Overview of Headless CMS

A headless CMS, sometimes abbreviated as HCMS, is a back-end content management system that delivers content through APIs, allowing developers to use their own front-end technologies for displaying the content. This separation of concerns enables greater flexibility and scalability in software development projects.

Key Benefits of Headless CMS

  1. Separation of concerns: By decoupling the front-end and back-end, developers can work independently, enabling faster development cycles and reduced dependencies.
  2. Flexibility: Headless CMS provides more freedom in choosing the presentation layer, as developers can select the most appropriate technology stack for their project.
  3. Scalability: Separating the back-end and front-end allows for scaling each layer independently, ensuring optimal performance as the project grows.
  4. Better security: Since the front-end and back-end are not tightly coupled, vulnerabilities in one layer do not automatically affect the other, reducing the overall attack surface.

Popular Headless CMS Options

  1. Contentful: Contentful is a flexible and powerful headless CMS that offers a modern, API-first architecture. It allows developers to easily manage content and structure across multiple platforms and devices.
  2. Prismic: Prismic is a fast and developer-friendly headless CMS that offers a unique editing experience for content creators. It provides a powerful and intuitive API for fetching and manipulating content.
  3. Sanity: Sanity is a real-time headless CMS that allows developers to build custom content structures and workflows. It provides a powerful API for fetching and managing content, making it a popular choice for complex projects.
  4. Gatsby Cloud: Gatsby Cloud is a unique headless CMS option that focuses on providing a complete development environment for building static websites with modern JavaScript frameworks like React or Vue. It integrates seamlessly with other Gatsby plugins to provide a streamlined development experience.

When considering alternatives to WordPress for software development, headless CMS options offer several advantages. They provide greater flexibility, scalability, and security, while enabling developers to use their preferred front-end technologies.

Recap of Key Points

When considering alternatives to WordPress for software development, it is essential to weigh the pros and cons of each option. Some popular alternatives include:

  • Ruby on Rails: This is a full-stack web application framework written in the Ruby programming language. It is known for its “convention over configuration” philosophy, which promotes faster development and a more streamlined workflow.
  • Django: Django is a high-level Python web framework that encourages rapid development and clean, pragmatic design. It includes an ORM (Object-Relational Mapping) tool for working with databases and a robust admin interface for managing applications.
  • Laravel: Laravel is a PHP web application framework designed for modern web applications. It offers a clean, elegant syntax and is built with the model-view-controller (MVC) architectural pattern. Laravel has a rich set of features, including an ORM, authentication, and routing.
  • Express.js: Express.js is a minimal and flexible Node.js web application framework. It provides a robust set of features for building web and mobile applications, including middleware for handling routing, templates, and error handling.

Each of these alternatives has its strengths and weaknesses, and the choice of framework will depend on the specific needs of the project. It is important to evaluate the project requirements, team expertise, and development timeline when selecting a framework for software development.

The Future of WordPress in Software Development

WordPress has been a popular choice for software development due to its ease of use and versatility. However, as technology continues to advance, there are alternatives to WordPress that are gaining popularity. In this section, we will explore the future of WordPress in software development and what challenges it may face.

One of the main challenges that WordPress may face in the future is the rise of other content management systems (CMS) that offer more advanced features and functionality. Some of these CMSs include Drupal, Joomla, and Ghost. These platforms offer more advanced functionality, such as e-commerce integration, and may be better suited for larger, more complex projects.

Another challenge that WordPress may face is the increasing demand for headless CMSs. A headless CMS is a CMS that separates the front-end and back-end of a website, allowing for more flexibility and customization. While WordPress has some support for headless CMSs, other platforms such as Contentful and Strapi have gained popularity due to their focus on headless architecture.

Despite these challenges, WordPress remains a popular choice for software development due to its ease of use and large community of developers. WordPress has a vast library of plugins and themes that can be used to customize and extend the functionality of a website. Additionally, the WordPress community is constantly working to improve the platform and add new features, ensuring that it remains relevant in the future.

In conclusion, while there are alternatives to WordPress for software development, it remains a popular choice due to its ease of use and large community of developers. As technology continues to advance, it will be interesting to see how WordPress adapts and evolves to meet the changing needs of software development.

Final Thoughts and Recommendations

When it comes to software development, WordPress is just one of many options available. While it may be a popular choice for website development, there are other platforms that may be better suited for certain types of software projects.

  • Comparing Platforms: Before deciding on a platform, it’s important to compare the pros and cons of each option. This can help you determine which platform will best meet the needs of your project.
  • Consider the Project Requirements: The specific requirements of your project can play a big role in determining which platform is the best fit. For example, if your project requires heavy customization or integration with other systems, a different platform may be more suitable.
  • Think about the Long-term Maintenance: Another important factor to consider is the long-term maintenance of the software. Some platforms may require more ongoing maintenance than others, which can impact the overall cost and sustainability of the project.
  • Open Source vs. Proprietary Software: Finally, it’s worth considering whether you want to use open source or proprietary software for your project. Open source software can be a good choice for projects that require flexibility and customization, while proprietary software may be better suited for projects that require more support and stability.

Ultimately, the best platform for your software development project will depend on a variety of factors. By carefully evaluating your options and considering the specific needs of your project, you can make an informed decision that will set your project up for success.

FAQs

1. What is WordPress?

WordPress is a free and open-source content management system (CMS) based on PHP and MySQL. It is primarily used for creating websites and blogs but has evolved over the years to become a powerful platform for various types of digital content.

2. What is the role of WordPress in software development?

WordPress can be used as a software development platform for creating custom web applications, themes, and plugins. Its open-source nature allows developers to modify and extend its functionality to suit specific project requirements. Additionally, WordPress provides a user-friendly interface for non-technical users to manage content, making it a versatile solution for businesses and organizations.

3. Is WordPress a replacement for traditional software development platforms?

No, WordPress is not a replacement for traditional software development platforms. While it offers a range of features and functionality, it is primarily designed for content management and may not be suitable for complex software applications. Developers should choose the appropriate platform based on the specific requirements of their project.

4. What are some benefits of using WordPress for software development?

Some benefits of using WordPress for software development include its open-source nature, flexibility, and user-friendly interface. Developers can modify and extend its functionality using plugins and themes, and non-technical users can manage content without requiring technical expertise. Additionally, WordPress has a large and active community, making it easy to find support and resources.

5. What are some limitations of using WordPress for software development?

Some limitations of using WordPress for software development include its focus on content management, which may not be suitable for complex applications. Additionally, it may require customization and modification to meet specific project requirements, which can be time-consuming and require technical expertise. Finally, it may not be as secure as other platforms, so appropriate measures must be taken to ensure the safety of the application.

Why you DEFINITELY Should Learn WordPress.. as a self taught programmer

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *